Simply saying it doesn't make it so. The look is part of the storytelling. They had tried to produce Kilngon Augments. That was before the Kelvin was destroyed. And they are able to sit on chairs. https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Harcourt_Fenton_Mudd?file=Harry_Mudd_police_record.jpg It's the fact that you have holograms at all. As that could just be "modern looks for a dusty timeline" I want to make sure and ask: is Discovery set in the original or the Kelvin timeline? Yet despite his similar trajectory, there are bigger differences in the wider universe. Kelvin timeline - Memory Beta, non-canon Star Trek Wiki Star Trek: Major details revealed about new TV show, https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Harcourt_Fenton_Mudd?file=Harry_Mudd_police_record.jpg, Stack Overflow at WeAreDevelopers World Congress in Berlin, Favorite Question and Answers from Second Quarter 2023. As for the Kelvin timeline, it seems that there is now a created alternate timeline, where Spock didn't run off to the Guardian of Forever to prevent the contamination and save Romulus and Vulcan, which is where I hoped the story was going. The last feature film in the franchise, Nemesis, came out in 2002, and the prequel TV series,Star Trek: Enterprise, went off the air in 2005, leaving the legendary sci-fi property without a major live-action media presence for the first time in years. They are also aware of the Mirror Universe, where Michelle Yeoh's character was from. Star Trek: How Picard Connects to Both the Prime and Kelvin Timelines - CBR Whatever happens, season 2 has reached a point in Star Trek history where Discovery will have to decide once and for all. Avoiding memory leaks and using pointers the right way in my binary search tree implementation - C++. If that were true, it makes everything we know about Voyager's doctor and the issuea he had with mobility really weird. In the Prime timeline, the Constitution-class was built for a crew of around 200, and later refit to double that. Between 2006 and 2019, CBS Television and Paramount owners Viacom were separate companies. Given that this would take place after Nero has entered this timeline, that would mean things are different to the point where the mod wore off faster. In doing so, he kills Kirks father figure Christopher Pike. This contradicts previous canon that Replicators were a Next Generation era technology - Captain Janeway, in an episode of Voyager, states that in Captain Kirks time there were no replicators. Marcus tries to leverage Kirks hot-headedness by sending Kirk after Khan, who has fled to the Klingon homeworld of Kronos. (I barely even want to mention the Spore Drive, as it's so canonically inconsistent.). All rights reserved. Let me first challenge by saying that if we favor a prime placement, we still need to resolve some problems. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Huge surprise, Khan betrays Marcus, exacting vengeance on various Starfleet targets. I previously worked on Kotaku, and the Official PlayStation Magazine and website. Keeping track of the Kelvin timeline is important because there are still Star Trek properties operating in the prime timeline, such as Picard. Not many witnessed the mod so the expectation when these Klingons are encountered would be no surprise. This also means Spock disappeared into the alternate past, where he died, as mentioned in Star Trek: Beyond. Star Trek 4 Has To Leave The Kelvin Timeline Behind - Screen Rant It fits w/canon. The Kelvin Timeline Is One of Many Alternate Realities in Star Trek. Starfleet dropped the rescue effort entirely in the aftermath, and Picard resigned. Though many in the Federation opposed it, Picard spearheaded a massive evacuation effort to get as many people off Romulus as possible in the years before the supernova, only to have his rescue fleet destroyed by a surprise attack from a group of rogue synths. Archived post. Directed by J.J. Abrams and starring Chris Pine, Zachary Quinto, and Zoe Saldana, Star Trek introduced the world to new versions of classic characters like Kirk, Spock, and Uhura, and it took us. The uniform suggested they were from the mid-24th century, around the time of The Next Generation series. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. Until 2009, all canon Star Trek was set in the same timeline (although owing to time travel it was frequently subject to subtle changes). The Kelvin itself, even though it does not resemble anything we saw in the Prime Timeline, is indeed a Prime starship. The series has ripped reality apart for dramatic impact over the years and then scrambled to explain away the inconsistencies. The most recent Star Trek movies take place in the so-called Kelvin Timeline, but how do they connect to the Prime Universe and franchise canon? The Entire Star Trek: Discovery Timeline Explained - Looper For a long time, those consequences weren't directly explored in Star Trek live-action storytelling, but that changed with the 2020 series Star Trek: Picard. This included the development of the Vengeance, a powerful new Federation warship, and a new advanced torpedo design that Marcus hoped to use against the Klingons. I know this has to do with the butterfly effect but it still doesnt make sense to me. Star Trek: Discovery is set in the original timeline, not in the Kelvin one. Directed by J.J. Abrams and starring Chris Pine, Zachary Quinto, and Zoe Saldana, Star Trek introduced the world to new versions of classic characters like Kirk, Spock, and Uhura, and it took us back to their earlier days in Starfleet. Paramount wanted a prequel film, showing what led Captain James T. Kirk and the much loved, much memed, Spock to where audiences see them in The Original Series. Marcus' search eventually led to the discovery of Botany Bay and a group of enhanced superhumans in cryogenic stasis. Apr 15, 2021 #1 Star Trek Universe TV Head Alex Kurtzman Says Line Between Movies And Television Is "Gone" He also talks about how TV showrunners are coordinating their Star Trek stories. In-universe explanation for why is the TOS-era Enterprise is more austere than the Discovery? The sudden destruction of Vulcan and the losses in the Federation fleet during the battle with Nero, coupled with the growing hostility of the Klingons, spurred certain factions within Starfleet to seek a more militaristic approach to dealing with the future of the galaxy. What is the smallest audience for a communication that has been deemed capable of defamation? In another interview he also says, Were certainly endeavoring to be entirely consistent with Original Series canon.. They had to significantly alter the uniforms for the Kelvin timeline to be able to use them. This new reality, dubbed the "Kelvin" timeline, is where the events of the reboot trilogy are set. Should storytellers want to revisit it or perhaps do a big-old multiverse crossover like The Flash movie, it might become relevant. In fact at least one major one. First of all, I don't really give two craps what any of the writers or producers are saying about. Unfortunately for the Kelvin Timeline, it is stuck in limbo. Star Trek currently has Star Trek: Picard and Star Trek: Discovery running in the Prime Timeline, and more shows are on the way. In secret, he blackmails the reawakened Khan to help develop powerful weaponry, as well as warships for the federation. Bare with me. The relaunch novels carried on the greater trek universe post Nemesis. Star Trek: Picard is set after the establishment of the Kelvin timeline, providing further context to the catastrophic event that helped shape the alternate reality.All Star Trek television series and films prior to 2009 take place in what is known as the "Prime" timeline.The 2009 film, Star Trek, created an alternate reality known as the "Kelvin" timeline. (There was replicator-like tech in TOS but it was used by aliens or entities from the future.). Remember that the Kelvin timeline has things happening about 7 years earlier: Kirk takes command of the Enterprise in 2258 (original timeline, 2265), so the first Kelvin timeline film happens two years after ST: Discovery. Technically the Kelvin timeline and Prime timeline coexist and run concurrently together, so why not other variations? It went wrong and Dr Phlox had to use DNA from humans (Archer specifically) to cure the virus. Star Trek first graced. While CBS retained the rights to Star Trek on TV, Paramount was able to hold on to the film rights thanks to the 2009 film. A few comments I read before Star Trek: Discovery premiered indicated it was part of the original timeline, but after seeing the show I'm not 100% sure: many of the consoles we see here are similar to those in the current films. Anyone who did know about it would just assume it had passed by now. Kelvin was spun off the prime timeline when the enhanced romulan mining ship, Narada, traveled back in time and encountered the USS Kelvin as seen in the movie's opening. Yes I know. You know the one. The Franklin disappeared before that, so it exists in both timelines, which means a different version of it could theoretically pop up in Star Trek media that doesnt adhere to the Kelvin timeline. This is 10 years before Kirk's era and nearly a hundred after Archer. Breaking space news, the latest updates on rocket launches, skywatching events and more! Could ChatGPT etcetera undermine community by making statements less significant for us? Did Spock serve as Commander with Pike in the Kelvin timeline? It's just much easier to explain all of this as different because of Nero and Kelvin intervention. There are other instances of course, where the original timeline is destroyed [EX:"Year of Hell" (VOY)], but the timeline in which Star Trek (2009) occurs does NOT destroy the original timeline. RELATED: The Biggest Threat to Star Trek: Legacy Is Losing Terry Matalas. There is a clear divide to when the Prime timeline stops, and where the Kelvin timeline begins. Stack Exchange network consists of 182 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. According to Undiscovered Country, Klingon-Federation war is in cold gear for over 30 years in 2256, yet it's the Discovery that starts it? Is Star Trek: Discovery set in the original or the Kelvin timeline His Starfleet journey actually began when one of these fights was broken up by Captain Christopher Pike, a Starfleet officer familiar with Kirk's history and his father's heroism. Spurred on by Pike, Kirk joined Starfleet and eventually tricked his way onto the newly launched Enterpriseafter cadets in the Academy were called into service to help battle Nero. They didn't do that, instead leaning into the science fiction of it all. In Kelvin, however, the Franklin is half-buried after crashing into the surface of the planet Altamid. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. The attack by Nero that created these two divergent realities happened in 2233, the end of season 1 sees the Discovery make contact with the TOS-era Enterprise in 2257 when Commander Pike is still captain. Picard takes place long after the titular character has quit Starfleet, and early on we discover the destruction of Romulus was why. Its a stretch though. - Aster Oct 5, 2017 at 2:28 2 There's a third option: It's post-Enterprise timeline. If Discovery does take place in the original timeline, then Lorca's schematic may be an unused early model or conceptual refit sketch. The movies of Star Trek's Kelvin Timeline exist in an entirely separate continuity to the franchise's Prime Universe, and though this development was entirely necessary to ensure the movies had a chance at success, the popularity of the Kelvin Timeline is utterly unique. The Kelvin timeline is rather hit-and-miss among fans of the Star Trek franchise. And when you know that, it's very difficult to put them in jeopardy in a way that feels fresh or original. You can find more of her work at Wired, IGN, Polygon, or look for her on Twitter:@SusanArendt. According to the most successful, most tested scientific theory ever, quantum mechanics, it continues. In that same interview he also points to The Next Generation episode Parallels (where Worf slips from one reality to another after passing through a quantum fissure). If youre Star Trek, you create the Kelvin Timeline. Kelvin. Star Trek Hints TNG Era Knows About Abrams' Kelvin Timeline In the Kelvin timeline, though, it was Kirk who sacrificed his life in the battle with Khan. Today, you can't even get some of the parts. It would be easier to say that Mudds life went differently as a branch result of the Kelvin event. The Kelvin was destroyed, and Nero's reign of terror continued in what was now an alternate reality. Reddit, Inc. 2023. (I suspect director Frakes was making a Star Wars reference to go with Isaacs' imitation of other Star Trek actors.). The Next Generation establishes that replicators werent really on ships until the 24th century, some 110 years after the events of Discovery. The similarities and differences continue into the second film Star Trek: Into Darkness where audiences are introduced (or perhaps re-introduced) to the one and only Khan Noonien Singh. Few of its former crew remain, and those that do are unrecognizable, having been transformed by technology theyve used to keep themselves alive. There's also evidence within the series itself. Kelvin Spock had been planning to rejoin what remains of the Vulcan people, but instead chooses to honor his other self by remaining in Starfleet. As the Kelvin is destroyed, it sets about the start of the new timeline, named in honor of the ships' sacrifice. Released: July 6, 2016 Rewards Experience Points: 9159 Expertise: 9550 Dilithium Ore: 480 You will receive the following reward: [Kelvin Timeline Bat'leth Mk XI] [Console - Tactical - Directed Energy Distribution Manifold Mk XI] [Console - Tactical - Prefire Chamber Mk XI] [Console - Tactical - Warhead Yield Chamber Mk XI] I'm GamesRadar's Senior Guides Co-ordinator, which means I run GamesRadar's guides and tips content. Certain that the admiral had already killed his people, Khan set out to become a one-man vengeance machine and destroy the Federation from the inside. 1 It's unclear if the schematic is from the rebel database or from Discovery's own records. Sure, they've addressed that no one has seen one in a hundred years. Curious about a secret project her father was working on, Marcus snuck aboard the Enterprise while utilizing her mother's maiden name. How did this hand from the 2008 WSOP eliminate Scott Montgomery? Instead the same stuff is happening just way earlier or in the case of DSC, dramatically different occurrences take place. RELATED: Star Trek: The Klingon Language, Explained. One of his first acts is to destroy the U.S.S. New York, There are some things we do know though. Order of events between Prime and Kelvin timelines. When Picard debuted in 2020, one of the reasons he effectively retired from Starfleet was because of the destruction of Romulus. But if this is Kelvin, we have an interesting solution. This meant that the entire was subjected to genetic modification and had their appearances altered. Enraged, a Romulan mining ship captain named Nero sought vengeance, and he attacked Spock's one-man vessel with his own ship, the Narada. Best Place For Mods: https://www.gamefront.com/games/bridge-co. Modern "Star Trek" adventures have embraced this aspect of the universe, as time travel was also the direct cause of the Kelvin Timeline featured in the 2009 "Star Trek" film and its sequels. Discoveries holograms not (at least not yet seen that they are). The latest run of Star Trek movies, starting in 2009, gave rise to a whole new timeline in the canon. From this point onwards, things follow a fairly similar chain of events to those who know the prime timeline, but things are all slightly different. See the HEART of @startrekcbs: it's real STAR TREK to its core.September 15, 2017, Theres no arguing that Discovery is Star Trek to its core but theres still so much that doesnt add up. My question is, why does everything not add up correctly? In DSC, the problem is not solidity. The resulting confrontation led to Kelvin timeline Spock seeking the advice of Spock Prime, who recalled the deadly consequences of battling Khan. In "Despite Yourself" (Discovery, season 1, episode 10), Captain Lorca refers to data, recovered from the mirror universe rebel ship, that describes the Terran Empire's acquisition of the USS Defiant (NCC-1764). The story of Star Trek's Kelvin timeline began in the Prime Star Trek universe in the 2380s, when it became clear that the Romulan sun presented a major danger not just to the Romulan Star Empire but to a whole quadrant of the galaxy. Outside of her writing passions, she is a passionate conservationist, trained Bee-keeper, archery dabbler and dog lover. Discovery Officially Makes JJ Abrams' Star Trek Movies Canon - Screen Rant But it's not a mystery to the Starfleet of the future. Susan Arendt is a freelance writer, editor, and consultant living in Burleson, TX. Star Trek's Kelvin Timeline, Explained - CBR Is there a word in English to describe instances where a melody is sung by multiple singers/voices? Why The Star Trek Movies Don't Need To Return To The Kelvin Timeline The Enterprise War. DSC Enterprise vs Kelvin-Timeline Enterprise It is a separate reality with its own history or future, depending on the storytelling perspective. Thats the Prime timeline - along with the Mirror Universe (the evil dimension where everyones bad), first introduced in a 1967 TOS episode called Mirror Mirror. These features are similarly missing from the ISS Enterprise (NCC-1701) in "Mirror Mirror"3: Nor does the schematic match the streamlined features of the several iterations of USS Enterprise from the Kelvin timeline: The wireframe design -- if it accurately depicts the USS Defiant -- precludes Discovery happening in the prime universe/original timeline. Kelvin. How big is the Kelvin Timeline USS Enterprise compared to the - Reddit This suggests that the Prime analog of the Kelvin would have been about the size of the Miranda-class, with a crew of around 100. @Thomas - I'm guessing the Terran Empire would have re-branded Defiant from USS to ISS, especially if they had upgraded it. Yes. While were talking about time periods its worth mentioning just how cleverly the show is set to avoid specifically identifying a Prime or Kelvin timeline outright. There's a third option: It's post-Enterprise timeline. It's an intriguing idea spinning out of the fun sci-fi adventure story thatBeyond offers. Lorca shows this schematic1: Although the schematic lists the ship as the USS (not ISS) Defiant, some features don't match the original, seen here (lower right) in "In a Mirror, Darkly, Part II"2 before the Empire had opportunity to modify it: For example, the wireframe has notches on the rim of the saucer, and a cylinder (parallel to the nacelle) at a bend in the nacelle pylon. On the first episode, Burnham gives the Stardate as 1207.3, and it being May 11, 2256. However, in the Kelvin timeline, it is Admiral Alexander Marcus who wakes Khan from his slumber. This set Kirk, Spock, and the Enterprise crew on a new, alternate trajectory to a confrontation with their old Prime universe foe. For now, the three films released in the early 21st century are as Star Trek as it gets while remaining a little pocket universe for folks to enjoy on its own merits. Perhaps from an event yet to happen in season 2 that creates a third timeline, and will finally explain the inconsistencies. He wants Spock to bear witness as the Narada drills a hole into the center of Vulcan and releases red matter at the planets core. And if you have a news tip, correction or comment, let us know at: community@space.com. Yes I say that because of visuals. i could not get "spoiler" bbl to work here.). J.J. Abrams Star Trek movies take place in an alternate reality known as the Kelvin timeline and the events of the films happen within the timeframe of Discovery seasons 1 and 2 and Strange New Worlds in the Prime timeline. Star Trek, Next Generation, Voyager, Deep Space Nine, and Enterprise, all take place there. But still the Fed did not implement any such tech. But why is Pike older and on Earth instead of commanding the NCC-1701 in the year 2258, just one year after he would have temporarily commanded USS Discovery? Ultimately, Paramount Pictures decided the way to bring Trek back was a prequel film but not just a typical prequel. 6 Star Trek Kelvin Timeline Counterparts What Star Trek movie/show are these images of a girl missing her school shuttle taken from? Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, You have to understand the timelines and what the different universes were and how they all worked together., So season 1 interestingly ends juuust at the point where it would have to conclusively prove which universe its in. Ok. I'm confused as hell after I saw the episode chronology recently posted on r/startrek. Star Trek's success dates back to the 1960s, when Gene Roddenberry's singular vision challenged societal norms by painting a . RELATED: Strange New Worlds Explores the Lingering Trauma of War With M'Benga. As the Romulan vessel attacked, First Officer George Kirk took command of the Kelvin after the death of his captain, and he sacrificed the ship to protect the escape shuttles fleeing the area,including the one carrying his wife and newborn son, James Kirk. The Biggest Threat to Star Trek: Legacy Is Losing Terry Matalas. The starships look similar, for example, but the designs are altered in many ways, and the same is true of things like phasers, communicators, and Starfleet uniforms. Visit our corporate site. Oct. 5, 2022 Paramount Ever since the Star Trek timeline was split in 2009, fans have wondered if we'll see additional crossovers between the reboot "Kelvin Universe" and the Prime Universe. I'm not very good about the Star Trek lore can someone explain what the Kelvin and Prime timelines are and why they should (or shouldn't) be merged? Co-writer for the 2009 Star Trek movie Roberto Orci backed this up in an interview when asked if the new timeline had wiped out the old one, answering, it continues. Star Trek: The Kelvin Timeline, Explained - Game Rant The films show Yorktown alone as something that doesn't exist in the Prime Timeline. Kelvin, this alternate reality set the stage for three different Star Trek feature films, all of which remixed original series continuity in some form or another. So some facts about the Prime timeline that are established in the Kelvin timeline movies are clearly canon to it (Transwarp Beaming, Red Matter, Kirk's father). The first installment of his superhero fiction book, TALES OF ADVENTURE & FANTASY, is available on Amazon in print and ebook! (The following has spoilers. In doing so he created a divergent timeline that was subtly different to the Prime one (and cleverly explained why so much was different in the reboot). By using our Services, you agree to our use of cookies. Eventually, both Spocks met each other and attempted to rebuild Vulcan culture through their shared knowledge and experience. While, canonically, Spock has existed on four separate timelines: the Original Series, an animated series timeline where time traveling saw him die as a child, requiring him to nip back in time to pretend to be his own cousin to fix it. ", Star Trek Discovery - every Easter egg and secret reference hidden in season 1. That being said, I think the stardate argument is weak. This wasn't just another reboot, though. Over 100 space rocks collected by meteorite hunter Geoffrey Notkin are up for action today, How California museum is protecting space shuttle Endeavour against earthquakes, Gorgeous photos show SpaceX's next Starship Super Heavy booster on the launch pad. Star Trek's Prime Timeline Crossed Over With Kelvin On Discovery Star Trek: Discovery season 3 revealed that the 32nd century United Federation of Planets has long been aware of the Kelvin Timeline. Stuff should still happen way closer to their original time placements.. While Nero arrived in the Kelvin timeline in 2233, Spock didn't actually emerge from the black hole until 25 years later, and he found the vengeful Romulan waiting for him. I did see a Klingon named Kol who is from a house called Kor, so, maybe Kor is leading Kol in an admiral type roll due to differences caused by the Kelvin event. He wakes one of them up Khan Noonien Singh and forces him to build weapons that Earth could use to defend itself against alien threats. Getting back to it, I believe a case could be made that DSC fits in either timeline but I favor Kelvin. In 2009, Paramount Pictures released Star Trek, the first film in what would become a new action-oriented trilogy to reinvigorate the franchise at the worldwide box office. Why did Khan come out of stasis so early and why did Kirk's five-year mission start in 2260 instead of 2265? The alternate reality differed from the primary reality in a number of capacities, including the attack upon the USS Kelvin, the launch of the USS Enterprise in 2258, and the . So there's evidence it's not in the Kelvin timeline. All things considered: Discovery is decent, and, it hits the fan service beats, but, whether they think they are or not, they are doing a story that fits in better if its an extension of the Kelvin timeline rather than a story that neatly fits in to the robustly detailed prime timeline. What this means for us is simple. Operating under the name John Harrison, Khanstaged successful attacks on Starfleet facilities that resulted in the death of Admiral Christopher Pike. Star Trek's Kelvin Timeline Was Inevitable (But Its Success Is Unique) When evacuation efforts failed, Spock now an ambassador from his homeworld of Vulcan intervened in 2387 with his own attempt to halt the supernova through the use of red matter. However, Star Trek Beyond, the last film of Abrams' trilogy, happens 3 years before Captain Kirk (takes command of the Starship Enterprise in the Prime timeline. Theres a Prime timeline, a Kelvin one, the Mirror Dimension and more time travelling and universe hopping than several other shows combined. This all came to a rather disappointing stop, however, back in 2005 when the Star Trek: Enterprise went off the air, leaving a large void for the first time in years. Plus, the J.J. Abrams reboots divergent timeline where a future and current version of the same character co-exist. This is also the point at which Ambassador Spock leaves the timeline due to the passing of the peerless Leonard Nimoy. Well, the answer was the introduction of an alternate reality that would link the new Star Trek film series to past canon, while also allowing filmmakers to go their own way. I suppose since: he was not caught in the Betazoid bank heist, that would not be on his record either, and, i guess: the "Future Police" would not count charges by the Klingon Empire, so, whatever he did there would also be absent, but.DAMN!, they took a lot of . liberty. with the Mudd character, and, its on thin ice with prime continuity. This dates beautifully placed, as its just close enough to some big events without clearly picking a side. Being a Romulan, Nero, despite his confusion, seeks out and attacks the nearest Federation ship, which just so happened to be the U.S.S. In the Kelvin timeline, Pike meets Kirk in 2255, and you see a variety of Starfleet uniforms that look similar to the ones used three years later in 2258 (not counting the shipboard uniforms). English abbreviation : they're or they're not. The characters and situations in the movies were off-limits . Unless purely new people were watching the film, there would not be the same amount of drama or suspense, especially when they know how these characters die (and thus know that they dont die in the new film). He organized a massive fleet to rescue the Romulan people, but an attack (orchestrated by Romulan spies) prevented it from happening. A malfunction there would certainly fit in with the priority one distress call the season ends on. This was a big deal remember. This is where things start to get complicated. However, what happened to him and Nero's ship is likely a mystery to Starfleet at that time.
Camp Pinehurst Salisbury Md,
How To Do Spiritual Meditation At Home,
Roanoke College Inquire,
Spa Edinburgh City Centre,
Articles K